SEMrush vs SpyFu: Which All-In-One SEO Solution Wins?

To sustain this free service, we receive affiliate commissions via some of our links. This doesn’t affect rankings. Our review process.

SEO marketing tools vary widely in their capabilities. Some are highly specialized in one or two areas, while others try to cover all the SEO bases. The latter is the case with two enormously popular SEO tools, SpyFu and SEMrush.

Both SEMrush and SpyFu offer a suite of SEO features, from keyword research and tracking to backlink tools. They also both specialize in diving deep into what your competitors are doing, but which one comes out on top?

Visit SEMrush’s Website | Visit SpyFu’s Website

Keyword Research

SpyFu has a powerful keyword research tool that gives you insight into how each keyword you enter is ranking and stats about search volume, daily clicks and more. SEMrush, however, provides this data and much more.

SEMrush has one of the best keyword research tools you’ll find. It gives you hundreds of suggestions, advanced filtering, including by broad, phrase or exact match, difficulty, words it begins or ends with, difficulty and many more filters. SpyFu’s related keyword results and filtering options are sparse compared to SEMrush.

When it comes to search volume accuracy, both companies have dedicated a lot of time and resources to make these reports as accurate as possible. We did not find a noticeable difference in the volume reports.

Winner: SEMrush

SEMrush Keyword Research

SpyFu Keyword Research

Backlink Analysis

SEMrush’s backlink analysis tools far outshine what you get with SpyFu. SpyFu essentially is a keyword search tool for potential backlinks. You can find backlinks that already help other sites rank and common backlinks your competitors get.

SEMrush’s backlink checker, on the other hand, gives you in-depth analysis into your current backlinks. It shows you which links are pointing to your website. You can check these incoming links for a URL, domain, or root domain, view the URLs and titles of linking and target web pages and compare inbound links’ weight on competitors’ domains.

SEMrush also indicates how authoritative a referring domain is and its location. They give you handy charts that place each backlink type into categories based on percentages (follow vs nofollow, source country, links that are text, image or form, etc.).
SEMrush also lists backlinks that you’ve lost.

Winner: SEMrush

SEMrush Backlink Analysis

SpyFu Backlink Analysis

Competitor Analytics

SEMrush and SpyFu blow other SEO tools out of the water with their competitor analytics. This area is SpyFu’s top selling point, but SEMrush gives them a run for the money.

Both allow you to “spy” on your competitors SEO and PPC strategies and practices. You can see how all of their keywords are ranking, including their most profitable keywords and ads for paid and organic searches.

You can also get a thorough picture of which keywords your competitors are bidding on and how much traffic they’re generating. Some differences between SEMrush and SpyFu include:

• SpyFu gives you unlimited search results with its two higher plans; SEMrush has caps with each pricing tier (but they’re generous).
• SpyFu’s higher plans let you dig into your competitors’ data going back 10 years. SEMrush goes back to 2012.
• SEMrush does a better job of analyzing your competitors’ social media and PR campaigns.

Winner: SEMrush & SpyFu (Tie)

SEMrush Competitor Analytics

SpyFu Competitor Analytics

Keyword Tracking

Both SEMrush and SpyFu have robust keyword tracking capabilities and come out about even overall. They allow you to track paid and SEO keyword rankings on Google, Bing and Yahoo. However, some key differences could be the deciding factor for your site’s needs.

• While SEMrush lets you check keyword rank changes over any set period (up to a year looking back), SpyFu’s higher pricing plans go even further back (up to 10 years).
• SEMrush tracks keywords daily; SpyFu tracks them weekly.

Winner: SEMrush & SpyFu (Tie)

SEMrush Keyword Tracking

SpyFu Keyword Tracking

User Friendliness

SpyFu isn’t the ideal tool for beginners. You get a lot of raw data that can be difficult to decipher if you’re not an SEO guru, and the UI can be confusing. SEMrush is simply easier to use for both beginners and pros.

If you need tech support, both SEMrush and SpyFu offer live chat, phone and email ticket support Monday through Friday. SEMrush’s hours are 10am-6pm EST. SpyFu’s are 7am-8pm.

Winner: SEMrush

Pricing

SpyFu is one of the most affordable SEO tools on the market, so they have a clear advantage in this category over SEMrush.

If you’re a small business or startup, SpyFu could be a wise, budget-friendly choice — provided you don’t need the well-rounded suite of SEO features you’ll get with SEMrush and the learning curve you’ll need to master SpyFu.

SEMrush offers an Enterprise level plan, but you must contact them for pricing. They also provide custom plans. For example, you can pay a la carte if you just want to add another session (simultaneous login) or user.

Free Trial/Money-Back Guarantee

Neither product offers a free trial. SpyFu, however, comes out ahead with a 30-day money-back guarantee, while SEMrush only offers a 7-day money-back guarantee.

Winner: SpyFu

List Of Features

It’s difficult to compare the specific features of different SEO tools, but we want to give you a summary for each company.

SEMrush

5+ years historical data Site audit On-page SEO checker Position tracking Social media tracker Backlink audit Marketing calendar Brand monitoring Post tracking

Content audit PPC keyword tool Organic research Keyword research Keyword magic tool Organic traffic insights Ad builder Advertising research Display advertising

Backlinks SEO content template Keyword difficulty Gap analysis Traffic analytics Lead generation tool Topic research My reports API access

SpyFu

10+ years historical data Unlimited searches Unlimited data exports Unlimited backlink results 3-way domain comparisons Advanced contact information

SEO performance analysis AdWords advisor reports Keyword cost-per-click Request keywords Customizable branded reports Keyword rank tracking

Estimated advertising spend Exclusive keywords SERP analysis Search filters Ranking graphs API access

Overall Winner

SEMrush wins our competition for its comprehensive suite of SEO tools. No other software comes close to SEMrush’s detailed ability to cover all of your SEO and PPC needs. SEMrush is also much easier to use and understand all the data than SpyFu.

However, if you’re mainly looking for competitive analytics and in-depth PPC/advertising data, you can’t beat SpyFu’s pricing. This could be a significant deciding factor for small businesses or startups.

Both SEMrush and SpyFu are industry leaders, and you can’t go wrong with either tool. Mainly, your choice comes down to your site’s specific goals and how competitive your market is. We are customers of SEMRush and use most of their features in our SEO marketing.

Winner: SEMrush

SEMRush vs SpyFu (Video)

A rather simple video that does a basic comparison of SEMRush and SpyFu features with either a checkmark or an X (depending on whether the service supports that feature), along with some explanation of what each feature does.

How Do These Two Stack Up To The Competition?

SEMRush and SpyFu are only two players in a highly competitive niche. Our experts compare the top SEO solutions in a comprehensive showdown, with over a dozen providers covered. You’ll get a breakdown of each tool’s features, pros and cons, pricing and more. We also outline which tools are good for “all-in-one” use vs those that offer unique features that pair well with other tools.

Have you had any success using an SEO tool?

Comments:

2 Comments