Does email marketing seem like an ancient method of communicating with your followers? Think the opposite, because it’s far from outdated.
In fact, the ROI is $54.33 for every $1.43 spent on email marketing (up from $35.64 the previous year)1, despite the proliferation of promising new digital channels.
There are hundreds of email marketing companies out there (we review over 20 of the top brands here!), so how do you weed them out and find the best one for your business? We give our recommendations for the best email marketing service providers as well as some other need-to-know information.
Article Overview
What Features Should Every Email Marketing Services Offer?
Most email marketing companies have standard offerings. We removed these common features from our criteria and pro and con lists below.
To even stay in business, an email marketing service provider (EMSP) needs to have relationships with the major ISPs (Internet Service Providers) such as Comcast, Charter, AT&T, Verizon, etc. If they didn’t, emails would get blacklisted, and clients, unable to reach their customers, would not be happy.
EMSPs all advertise that they have the best “whitelisting” relationships with ISPs, but the truth is — the arrangements are more or less the same. The important thing is that the EMSP has the support and staff necessary to maintain the relationships, analyze the SMTP send logs, etc.
Anti-Spam Policies
Along the same lines, an email marketing brand must have an anti-spam policy to keep many users from being blacklisted if one user misbehaves.
Constant Contact, Vertical Response, StreamSend, and iContact (and typically the rest of the lot) take the same anti-spam measures.
Common anti-spam measures, in accordance with CAN-SPAM (an official anti-spam policy), include:
A postal address
Unsubscribe option
Information on how the recipient joined the list in each email newsletter
Not use false or misleading headers and subject lines
These requirements got even more robust in May 2018 when the European Union introduced a General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). Compliance measures were put in place worldwide to meet these requirements, strengthening data privacy for all consumers.
A Note On Newsletter Archiving And SEO
Many service providers, such as Constant Contact, offer a free or paid service that archives your old email newsletters on its website. This isn’t always ideal for you from an SEO (Search Engine Optimization) perspective.
Your email newsletter contains valuable content relevant to your business that could be indexed by search engines. However, if the content is archived/hosted on the EMSPs servers, you won’t get credit for it and may miss out on valuable website traffic. Look to either archive your old newsletters on your own website or find a way to copy/paste the archive from the service over to yours.
Best Entry Level EMSPs
From our research, Benchmark, GetResponse, Campaigner, MailChimp, StreamSend, VerticalResponse, Constant Contact, iContact, and ActiveCampaign provide the best entry-level opportunities for small businesses.
Online support communities (where users can interact with other users, share their opinions on the service, as well as get support from administrators and an extensive knowledge base)
Best Email Marketing Providers
We’ve chosen the top 3 picks for email marketing based on features, price, customer service, usability, and more.
GetResponse’s user-friendly interface and email intelligence make it one of the easiest programs to jump into and get emailing in no time, and it has more than 350,000 customers to prove it.
GetResponse actively helps you improve your campaigns to better reach and connect with your audience every step of the way. Other perks include online surveys, inbox preview, autoresponders, and social networking integration. It gets high marks for customer service, which goes a long way in our book.
You get a lot of bang for your buck with its monthly accounts — more than most other email marketing service providers. What are its limitations? Advanced list segmentation and HTML-based email customization.
Best Email Marketing Service For Nonprofits
GetResponse is our top pick for best for nonprofits since they offer a significant (50% off) discount.
Award-winning customer support is available via email and 24/7 live chat
Time Travel sends your email at the optimal local time to maximize the open rate
Creating a newsletter is incredibly intuitive with Email Creator; advanced users have access to a full HTML editor
List Booster allows you to import email addresses 16 ways
Social sharing & analytics with Facebook, Twitter, Google+, LinkedIn, and Pinterest
Integrates with 100+ apps/software, including PayPal, Google Analytics & more
Built-in statistics tracking service
1,000+ free iStock photos
Free survey feature
QR code generator
Multimedia Center: create audio and video files
Email Intelligence & enhanced reporting features
Spam Assassin integrates with the message editor
RSS to email
Inbox preview
Landing Page Creator
Webinars
iPhone and Android app
No phone support
Once you’ve uploaded images to their database, it might prove difficult to find the imported images to use
Email design customization is limited compared to other services
Must pay extra for dedicated IP address
List segmentation is limited
No free plan
Price
GetResponse’s fees are on a per-month, per-contact pricing scale, and there is no contract to sign or cancellation penalty. All include an unlimited number of emails. If you’re looking for longer-term use, you can save some substantial money with their annual 18% discount or 30% discount for two-years (prices below don’t reflect this discount, and you must pay ahead of time).
In addition to the plans below, GetResponse also offers an Enterprise-level plan for 100,000+ employees, but you must contact them for pricing.
GetResponse gives nonprofit 501 (c)(3) organizations a 50% off “forever” discount on all of its pricing.
iContact moves up to our second spot for the best email marketing service provider this year. iContact offers very competitive pricing plans for its basic services (starting at $12.75/month for 500 subscribers) with a wide array of features and a solid deliverability reputation.
Its premier offerings, however, seem to be its best selling point. With iContact’s marketing services, you get a dedicated account manager to focus on your email design, campaign, and analytics. Still, it’s unclear how much this will cost you — you have to contact the company for pricing.
Good strategic advising support with their marketing services
Competitive pricing
Unlimited users with every account
Offers flexible options for subscriber sign-up forms
HTML editor for email newsletter templates
Seamless integration with Salesforce for stronger CRM programs
List segmentation by demographics, interests, and subscriber behaviors
Free Getty Images photo stock library
Supports 5mb for free online image storage
Developer portal and API
Comprehensive contact manager with bounce-back handling & history reports
97% delivery success rate
Spam checking
Data tracking, see who opens, clicks, and unsubscribes from your emails
Autoresponders
Social media management tools
Split A/B testing
iPhone and Android mobile apps
No weekend customer support
Could have more varied email templates
RSS to email is limited and hard to use
Integration of software/apps is fairly limited (no Google Analytics integration)
Price
iContact offers two email marketing platforms — their basic services and XE services — which include advanced marketing automation and email personalization as well as advanced e-commerce features.
Their fees are very competitive compared to other providers. Its pricing is based on the number of contacts per month, and you can pay monthly — no long-term contract is required. You receive a 15% discount on monthly pricing if you purchase the annual plan. It also provides a 20% discount for nonprofit 501 (c)(3) organizations (free account for North Carolina-based nonprofits). iContact has a 30-day free trial.
iContact Basic
Number of Contacts
Price Per Month for Base
Price Per Month for Pro
1,500
$15
$30
2,500
$25
$50
5,000
$45
$90
iContact XE
You can customize the following plans by contacting iContact.
Coupon Code
Use this link to get the best deal we can offer from iContact.
Constant Contact is one of the oldest and best-known email marketing services around — it’s been in business since 1996. One of its biggest selling points is that it’s easy for beginners to get up and running in no time. The platform makes it easy to manage your contacts, segment mailing lists, use email templates, generate reports, investigate analytics, and much more.
However, to get advanced features, like trigger-based messaging and split A/B testing, you’re going to have to upgrade your pricing plan. These are features that many other services include in base plans — and the main reason Constant Contact doesn’t fall into our top 2 spots. It’s also expensive compared to our top 2 picks. But if you can fit it into your budget, it’s one of the easiest platforms to use.
Award-winning phone and live chat support available late at night during the week
400+ email newsletter templates
Create your own designs with the HTML editor
Event and survey features
370+ apps/integrations, including Google Analytics
Good marketing automation, trigger and behavioral messaging
Track your campaigns in real-time to see what works and what doesn’t
Premium marketing services advisor program available (similar to iContact)
30-day money-back guarantee
Expensive compared to similar services
No live customer support on Sundays
Must upgrade for additional features that competitors include in basic plans
Must upgrade to Plus Plan for more than one user
No RSS feed to email (but coming soon)
Some users say it’s hard to cancel your subscription
Price
Pricing for Constant Contact is on a per month basis. You get a 10% discount on the following prices if you pre-pay for 6 months or a 15% discount for 12 months. Constant Contact also offers an email marketing service called Email Plus which includes email automation, online surveys, events management, online donations, and more.
Number of Contacts
Price Per Month For Email
Price Per Month For Email Plus
0-500
$20
$45
501-2,500
$45
$70
2,501-5,000
$65
$95
5,001-10,000
$95
$125
10,001-15,000
$195
$195
15,001-25,000
$225
$225
25,001-30,000
$295
$295
30,001-35,000
$315
$315
35,001-50,000
$335
$335
50,000+
Call 855-783-2308
Call 855-783-2308
Coupon Code
Use this link to get the best deal we can offer from Constant Contact.
If you are confused by the terminology we use in this table, you will find our definitions of industry terms helpful.
To see the full table, make sure you *use the scrollbar at the bottom* of the table. Alternatively, click on the table and use your arrow keys to scroll across.
Now that you have an idea of what EMSPs can offer you and our picks for the overall best 3 EMSPs, we’re going to dig a little more deeply into this industry to find the email marketing provider that fits the unique needs of your business or organization. Here are our winners that are “best for” the following categories:
Benchmark has stepped up its competitive edge with its Free Plan for Life. It allows you unlimited subscribers and 250 emails per month with many standard and advanced features that other service providers don’t offer for free.
On top of that, Benchmark offers free surveys, polls, and event marketing, as well as the option of having a private IP address ($28.95 per month) and a dedicated server ($199 one-time setup fee) for large-volume senders. The majority of providers don’t even offer these extended features.
What we like is that Benchmark genuinely cares about its customers’ concerns. They showcase this in their in-dash feedback forum that allows you to voice your concerns without navigating away from the page. Click here to get started with its Free Plan for Life.
Pros
Cons
Fantastic customer service
Intuitive marketing team will assume all responsibility and create marketing campaigns for you with only an email list, pictures, and an idea of what you want to say
One of the few providers with a free forever plan
Interactive video and links make email campaigns look great and stand out from other template designs
Fantastic systematic approach and drag and drop features make designing and producing templates easy to understand and easy to do
10mb image hosting, 50mb for high-volume accounts
Social sharing with Facebook, Twitter, Pinterest, and LinkedIn
HTML template archive
Split A/B testing, inbox preview
API access, RSS to email
Event marketing, polling, and survey features with easy to use templates
Dozens of app integrations, including Google Analytics, Zapier, PayPal, Salesforce, and more
Solid tracking and reporting features and list management
Mobile apps for iPhone and Android
Limited phone support (hours are unlisted), but they do offer live chat 24/7
Private IP address costs an extra $28.95 per month, regardless of your subscriber plan
Does not allow for the use of attachments in marketing campaigns, but they do give you up to 10mb per file to store and link to them on their server
Built-in import features for third-party address books are very limited
No social media or sales tracking
Price
Below is some of the Benchmark Email pricing. Visit Benchmark’s website for a full pricing list. Benchmark also gives you the option of upgrading image hosting from 10MB for free to unlimited for $5/month. Nonprofit 501(3)(c) organizations get a 25% discount on all services.
Pinpointe is an advanced service geared toward B2B (business to business) email marketers and larger volume senders. It delivers all the features advanced email marketers want, and its automation is one of the best we’ve seen.
It includes sub-accounts for universities and larger companies (in the Enterprise version), surveys, advanced reports, including click heat maps, easy to use campaign builders, and trigger and drip campaigns with flexible and dynamic segmentation. While some of the more sophisticated services can get overwhelming, Pinpointe offers a surprisingly easy, intuitive interface, and users rave about the knowledgeable and responsive customer service.
Unlimited image hosting and more than 1,000 templates
Offers unbranded emails with any paid account
User-friendly interface and wizard make the process easy
Unused email credits roll over each month up to one year
Inbox preview with 50+ email clients
Excellent autoresponders, A/B split testing, behavioral targeting, and triggered campaigns
Real-time tracking and analytics
Google Analytics and Salesforce integration
XML API connector for developers
Social sharing with Facebook, Twitter, and LinkedIn, including tracking and reporting
RSS archiving
Robust survey feature with drag and drop, customizable editor, and analytics
Could use more customer support hours considering it’s a higher-end service — no weekend phone or live chat hours, and weekday hours are only from 9am-6pm EST
Cheapest monthly plan listed starts at $49 for 5,000 contacts
Several user reviews that it’s challenging to set up
Apps/integrations don’t appear to be nearly as numerous as competitors
Price
Pinpointe offers 10% off the following prices if you pre-pay for 6 months.
Number of Contacts
Monthly Number of Emails Send Limit
Price Per Month
10,000
100,000
$74
25,000
250,000
$150
50,000
500,000
$245
75,000
750,000
$365
100,000
1,000,000
$480
200,000+
Call
$898
Coupon Code
Use this link to get the best deal we can offer from Pinpointe.
Initially designed for online merchants, SendinBlue has made great strides (60,000 global customers) since launching in 2012. Its approach combines email marketing campaigns, transactional emails, and SMS (text) mobile messaging to best meet its users’ needs. They gear many of their best features toward the customer sales process.SendinBlue also stands out for its free plan with unlimited contacts and 300 emails per day.
There are some notable missing features, but there’s been a lot of buzz about SendinBlue recently, so we think it’s worth trying out. Some significant features include marketing automation (send target emails based on a contact’s activity), email heatmap (know where customers click most), and dynamic list (create lists that are updated every 24 hours based on filters).
Mailigen is a great option for beginners and experts alike due to its effortless customizations and a wide array of features that make crafting a unique marketing strategy fun and effective. There are a few shortcomings, however, like limited stock images and template selections. All things considered, Mailigen is a fantastic option loaded with features that make for a reliable product.
Employ deliverability specialists and strategic account representatives who provide top of the line help and support
One of the most affordable services we’ve found for the number of features you get
Custom template design services are available (price unknown)
You can request your own IP address,which further protects you against spam and malware
Best SMS (text) integration we’ve seen includes SMS list segmentation, tracking, and reporting, plus you get 20 free SMS credits with every monthly account
Solid integration with Google Analytics, WordPress, Magento, Zapier, Facebook, Shopify, and more
Social media sharing options are impressive – Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, Google+, Reddit, and more
Dynamic Content and Behavioral Segmentation Features allow you to target particular interest groups, making custom emails cost-effective
Email Setup Wizard walks you through email content creation so that novice users can showcase professional-looking products
Drag and drop editor is one of the best we’ve seen, letting you incorporate video, images, social media buttons, and more into mobile-ready templates
No weekend customer support for phone and live chat
The resource section could be more helpful
Mailigen’s branding appears on every email for free trial users
Contact importing is limited, only allowing Excel, csv, and txt files
After your 20 free SMS credits, you must pay for additional credits
Price
Mailigen offers significant discounts off of the following prices if you pre-pay for 12 months. Check out their website’s sliding price scale to see more pricing options. There is a 25% discount for nonprofit 501(c)(3) organizations.
Subscribers
Price Per Month
500
$10
2,500
$25
5,000
$40
10,000
$60
15,000
$84
20,000
$104
25,000
$120
50,000
$200
100,000
$400
150,000
$555
200,000
$704
500,000
$1,500
850,000
$2,295
1,000,000
Contact Sales
Coupon Code
Use this link to get the best deal we can offer from Mailigen.
MailChimp is one of the most popular email marketing softwares, partly because it offers the best free plan compared to all other services. With the free plan, you get 2,000 subscribers and 10,000 emails per month, free forever.
MailChimp has a fun and straightforward interface and a lot of features for beginners and budget-conscious users. Some of MailChimp’s latest additions include shoppable landing pages, enhanced segmentation and tagging, postcards, and native integrations through their tool “Connected Sites,” including WooCommerce, Magento, BigCommerce, and many other sites.
In 2019 MailChimp added new features that several of the big-timers offer, including behavior-based triggered automation, social post scheduling and organic social posting, marketing CRM, and the ability to apply new contact tags in landing pages.
Pros
Cons
Free for up to 2,000 subscribers
Knowledge base includes animated videos and screenshots
MailChimp’s HTML templates are easy to use, and you can use their WYSIWYG editor to customize your own designs
An Inbox Inspector add-on that lets you generate over 25 screenshots of your email in all major email applications, as well as live tests from all the major ISPs to see if spam filters are triggered
Track where your sign-ups originated, which will help you optimize your opt-out prevention methods
Hundreds of integrations, including Google Analytics
Sign-up forms can be customized and embedded anywhere
Straightforward contact list management and easy import of contacts via csv file
Internal surveys
Automation feature makes autoresponding, segmentation, and triggering easy
Automatically removes old/incorrect email addresses that bounce to keep lists healthy
No phone support and live chat often has long wait times
Fewer templates than other email marketing services
Importing templates from existing website graphics would be a great add-on
Slow to refresh and can be slow when the site is busy
Segmentation is very limited with free plan
Price
MailChimp offers the best free plan for 2,000 subscribers and 10,000 emails sent and various features than any other email marketing service. It also provides monthly pricing and pay as you go fees for those who need more than what you can do with the free plan.
Monthly Subscriptions
With MailChimp’s monthly subscriptions, you pay per number of contacts, but you get an unlimited number of emails you can send each month. You can add Pro to your plan for $199 per month. Pro provides analytics tools to help grow your business.
Number of Contacts
Price Per Month for Essentials
Price Per Month for Standard
Price Per Month for Premium
500
$9.99
$14.99
n/a
2,500
$30.99
$51.99
n/a
5,000
$52.99
$79.99
n/a
10,000
$78.99
$99
$299
15,000
$135.99
$170
$370
20,000
$170
$200
$420
25,000
$200
$230
$480
30,000
$230
$270
$530
50,000
$270
$320
$640
100,000
n/a
$540
$750
200,000
n/a
n/a
$1,190
Pay As You Go Plan
MailChimp gives you the option of buying packages of email credits, which you use like postage stamps. These can be a great option if you’re on the free plan but occasionally need to send more emails than the 12,000 limit.
Number of Credits
Price
5,000
$150
10,000
$200
15,000
$300
50,000
$1.00
75,000
1,500
200,000
$2,000
2,000,000
$2,500
5,000,000
$5,000
25,000,000
$10,000
Coupon Code
Use this link to get the best deal we can offer from MailChimp.
Although not widely considered one of the big players in the email marketing service provider world, ActiveCampaign is certainly giving competitors a run for their money. ActiveCampaign has one of the slickest and most intuitive interfaces out there, and all the features you’ll need, whether you’re a novice or a pro.
Also, it has fully built-in CRM sales and automation, a ton of apps and integrations, and full API. However, there are a few drawbacks that keep it from rising to the top — if you need to do affiliate marketing, for example, look elsewhere. It’s strictly not allowed with ActiveCampaign. Still, this service brings a wow factor with its ease of use and affordable pricing.
What began as an autoresponder service is now a full-fledged email marketing provider — one of the more popular ones out there. AWeber recently acquired Omnistar, another popular email marketing provider, so it continues its growth as one of the major players in this space. AWeber prices itself competitively and is a strong contender in the email marketing battle.
What’s missing? AWeber isn’t as up to date on social media integrations and tracking as other top services, and its lack of assimilation with Google Analytics and other standard complimentary products could turn some away.
One cool feature is its broadcast archive, which optimizes the newsletter archiving process by turning newsletters into easy to use web pages for your visitors.
Aweber acquired Omnistar Mailer, a previous competitor in this space.
Campaign Monitor is an email marketing software built specifically with graphic designers in mind, but its drag and drop editor is easy to use for beginners. This interface is very pleasing to the eye and allows for multiple account management.
Campaign Monitor has most of the basics you’ll need to run successful email marketing campaigns, but if you’re looking for seriously advanced features, you may need to look elsewhere.
With Campaign Monitor, you have the option of paying per month or by campaign. The pay-by-campaign option is 1¢ per subscriber, plus $5 per campaign. So, if you send to 1,000 subscribers, you’ll pay $15 for the one-time send.
The pay-per-month option is based on your number of contacts, and for the Basic plan also the number of emails you send each month. The Unlimited plan is true to its name, allowing you unlimited number of emails sent each month, based on your number of contacts.
Campaigner has reasonable pricing and includes 50mb CDN, media/image hosting, A/B testing, social media integration, and autoresponders at no additional cost. And its award-winning customer service team is known for reliable tech support.
While Campaigner has been a top choice for small businesses for years, their user interface hasn’t kept up with their competitors, and customers report that the system has become too buggy and slow.
Campaigner acquired StreamSend in 2017. j2 Global, Inc. (owner of Campaigner) previously acquired Contactology in 2014.
Pricing for Campaigner is on a per month basis, based on your number of contacts. All of these plans allow for an unlimited number of emails sent.
Number of Contacts
Price Per Month
Up to 1,000
$19.95
Up to 3,500
$29.95
Up to 5,000
$49.95
Up to 10,000
$79.95
Up to 15,000
$99.95
Up to 25,000
$149.95**
Up to 50,000
$299.95**
Up to 100,000
$549.95†
Over 100,000
Call or request a quote online
** With the purchase of these higher-end plans, you get some of Campaigner’s more advanced features included in the price: Custom footer, 1GB CDN media hosting, suppressor list, projects and more. † And with the purchase of the “Up to 100,000” monthly plan you get even more features: Workflows, APIs, static segment sampling, dynamic content, 3rd party Ad content, delivery support and more.
ConvertKit is specifically designed for bloggers, podcasters, service-based business owners and YouTubers to help grow your audience and customers.
With ConvertKit’s features and visual automation builder, you can organize your subscribers based on their interests and activity and send them personalized emails. They also have customizable forms, email and live chat support, and over 80 integrations, including Zapier, Shopify and WooCommerce.
ConvertKit offers a free 14-day trial (no credit card required), and their pricing starts at $29 per month for up to 1000 subscribers. They also offer a 30-day refund.
Emma boasts helping big-name organizations like NPR, DISH, Tito’s, Serta, Girl Scouts and more with their email marketing needs. Emma emphasizes the service end of email marketing, and it shows in rave reviews of its customer service.
Its drag and drop email editor is easy to use, and it offers full image integration from Facebook and Flickr, which could mean the world to a small business looking for free image hosting. Emma is significantly more expensive than some other services, but as you work up the pricing scale, the prices become much more competitive.
Pros
Cons
Top notch customer service and professional services available
Easyto use drag and drop interface
Social media marketing with Facebook, Twitter and LinkedIn
Fully integrated with Facebook and Flickr for image hosting, as well as other social media for automatic content sharing
Solid integration offerings, including Salesforce, Shopify, a number of Formbuilder and CMS services (WordPress, Drupal)
Many of the standards: A/B testing, automation, list segmentation, contact management, tracking and reporting
No weekend customer service hours
Among the most expensive options we’ve reviewed, and no mention of a discount for nonprofit 501(c)(3) organizations
FireDrum offers a multitude of email marketing and automation services, from DIY (best for freelance to small businesses) to plans for marketing agencies and large companies. When you search its website, it can be overwhelming, because it has a wide variety of plans and services it offers for each plan.
The DIY plan starts at a free forever level, but it’s limited (only 100 subscribers and 500 emails per month), but the paid pricing levels are very competitive and include all the basic features you’ll need to get your email marketing up and running.
What’s great about FireDrum is the a la carte services offered if you don’t have time to take on the details, i.e., list assistance, HTML programming, campaign management, etc. All charge a fee, of course, but it’s a great option to have.
FreshMail’s paid plan is extremely affordable compared to similar EMSPs. You get a number of advanced features with an intuitive interface that makes the process simple and fun.
The downside of FreshMail? Since it’s based in the UK, its phone support hours are extremely limited. We’ve seen some excellent reviews about the high quality of its customer service.
FreshMail offers a 10% discount on its monthly paid plan if you pre-pay for 6 months and 15% for 12 months. Pay-as-you-go rates start at $30 for 5,000 emails.
Pros
Cons
Email support 7 days a week
Very competitive pricing
Pay-as-you-go credits don’t expire
Interface is extremely intuitive
All templates are responsive and beautifully designed
Good contact importing, including from Google, Basecamp, etc.
Inbox preview lets you see your email in 20+ email clients without sending test emails
40+ integrations, including Google Analytics, Salesforce, Zapier and more
Many advanced features included in affordable paid plan, including A/B testing, trigger messaging, social media reporting and more
Phone support is only available M-F 2am-10am
Some consumer complaints about slow moderation process
JangoMail began in 1998 as an elegant solution to a complicated problem. How to pull data from multiple servers (some local, some halfway around the world) and assemble it into a single mass email? That feature is JangoMail’s unique claim to fame, although it incorporates many other features, including foreign language support, in-depth personalization options and fully customizable RSS to email conversion.
For all of JangoMail’s incredible feature options, it comes with a price. It is one of the more pricey services out there and probably better for larger businesses or marketing agencies (it offers pretty extensive agency features, including multiple-users).
Price is based on number of emails sent per month, rather than the standard number of contacts per month, so depending on your business needs you can end up spending a lot more than you would with its competitors.
Mad Mimi doesn’t have all the bells and whistles of the top guns when it comes to email marketing providers, but we think that’s okay. Sometimes less is more if you don’t want to wade through features you won’t use.
Geared toward a simpler approach, Mad Mimi offers what most small businesses need with a very affordable price tag. Its standard features are solid, except split A/B testing and template selection variety. Yet it also provides a decent selection of apps/integrations, social sharing and a robust API, so it isn’t falling behind the technology times.
Pros
Cons
Friendly, responsive customer service
Live chat
A great value if you have larger mailing lists but don’t need a ton of advanced features
Easy drag and drop email building tools
Unlimited image hosting
Customizable web forms
Ability to have multiple users on your account
Solid tracking and reporting tools
Social sharing with Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, Google+ and more
Autoresponders, RSS to email, drip/targeted campaigns
40+ apps/integrations, including Google Analytics, Salesforce, Zapier and WordPress
Robust API for developers
User resources are pretty thin — no webinars or online community
No phone support unless you set up an appointment time
Email design tools could be too simple for some
Very limited template selection
No split A/B testing or mobile-ready templates
Its autoresponder is fairly basic compared to other providers
Automated contact importing is limited to csv files
Omnistar Mailer Review
Omnistar Mailer has been acquired by AWeber, a competing email marketing service provider that’s growing in popularity and becoming a contender as one of the top services. Omnistar got its start in 1999 in the real estate industry and became popular for its excellent autoresponder features.
Check out our AWeber Review to see how it compares to other services.
Salesforce Marketing Cloud has been around since 2000 and tags themselves as the future of marketing. While claiming to be from “humble” beginnings, this company now operates one of the more dominant email marketing and comprehensive marketing solutions on the market today.
Unfortunately, this growth into big business has created somewhat of an intimidating appearance for many smaller businesses seeking these services. But, if you are looking for a comprehensive marketing integration tool to put everything in one place and makes it easy to analyze all of your online marketing efforts, Salesforce Marketing Cloud may be perfect for you.
Pros
Cons
Live chat customer service allows for access to customer service without long phone wait times
Comprehensive marketing integration across email, mobile, social media, web, data and analytics make cross-platform marketing simpler
WYSIWYG email editor as well as an HTML email editor
Individually based pricing – Pricing for the Salesforce email marketing solution is based on an individual basis which is catered to each company’s unique needs
A/B testing, inbox preview
Coupon and barcode management
Automation, triggered messaging, drip campaigns
RSS feeds can easily and quickly be integrated into email sending
Hundreds of integrations with third-party apps like Google Analytics
Online database of step-by-step tutorials, videos, webinars and more
No listed customer service hours
No immediately available pricing information
Difficult learning curve – you need to be pretty tech savvy to best utilize their services
Call or complete its online email form. Unlike other email marketing service providers, Salesforce Marketing Cloud provides no pricing information online. It offers a number of different packages beginning with its Basic plan, and each step-up plan includes all of the features of lower tiered plans.
It indicates on its website that you can customize bundles based on your business needs, but it’s not clear how many specific features can be purchased a la carte.
SharpSpring, previously known as GraphicMail, is a young but popular marketing automation software solution that has received excellent reviews from its users so far.
What’s exciting is its behavior-driven features, which bring together personalized emails, autoresponders, analytics and more so you can drill down to each customer’s specific activities (translation: you can target them in the areas in which they engage the most). Other EMSPs offer this feature as well, but customer behavior seems to be SharpSpring’s main area of focus.
VerticalResponse has been in business since 2001, and it’s come a long way. It has launched some excellent new features in the last couple of years including a free plan, the addition of an autoresponder (free for a limited time) and a new API and developer program that gives small businesses even more marketing tools to expand their reach. If you are a not-for-profit 501(c)(3), you can apply for a free credit program.
Pros
Cons
Live chat, phone and email support (with paid plans)
Great free plan
Excellent nonprofit discounts
70+ responsive email templates and HTML templates
Landing page builder
Free built-in surveys
A/B split testing and autoresponders
Real-time reporting and statistics, accessible from any web browser
Pay as You Go option gives you flexibility each month
Offers 25MB of online image storage free for your newsletters
Free webinars and support seminars, along with video tutorials, on how to make the most of your email newsletter campaigns
Excellent support community. It appears that the support community has relatively fast response times, is well-organized, and has avid user interaction
Outdated UI that’s not easy to use
Far fewer integrations than other services
Their spam checking tools are very limited. For instance, you can’t get a spam score indicating the likelihood that your email newsletter will make it to your subscriber’s inbox
Below is the pricing for email marketing through VerticalResponse.
Free Plan
VerticalResponse now offers a pretty impressive free plan available to anyone with no limited time offer. You can have up to 300 subscribers and send 4,000 emails per month at no charge.
Monthly Subscriptions
For those looking to send emails more frequently or for those with larger email lists, you can purchase monthly plans, which include an unlimited number of emails sent. Monthly prices increase as you add more subscribers, but paying a bit more gives you some added perks.
Number of Contacts
Basic*
Pro**
Pro+***
1-500
$11
$16
$196
501-1,000
$22
$32
$212
1,001-2,500
$33
$48
$228
2,501-5,000
$55
$80
$260
5,001-10,000
$83
$120
$300
10,001-25,000
$160
$232
$412
25,001-40,000
$250
$363
$500
*Basic Plan:
Send unlimited emails
Send automated follow-up emails to contact
Award-winning phone and live chat customer support
Remove VerticalResponse logo from your emails
Create & publish multiple Landing Pages
**Pro Plan:
Analyze campaigns by engagement, device, browser, domain & geography
See heat maps of where your contacts are clicking
Automate campaigns with autoresponders and email series
Optimize campaigns with subject line testing
Get 10 Test Kit credits per month
***Pro+ Plan:
Work with an expert campaign strategist who will create and send emails for you
Receive 1 expert-created promotional email per month
Receive 1 expert-created newsletter email per month
Receive 8 expert-created social posts per month
Receive tailored reports and suggestions for optimization
How To Change Email Marketing Service Providers?
Let’s say you’ve decided you want to switch to another provider, such as from iContact to Constant Contact. How painful will the transition process be?
Export Your Subscriber List
Fortunately, any good email marketing provider should allow you to export your subscriber list. You can then import the subscriber list into your new email marketing provider. That’s the easy part.
Transfer Your Archives
You should also consider how you will move your newsletter archives, so you do not lose this valuable content you have created over the years. The more difficult part, depending on how your website is set up, will be replacing all the sign-up boxes you have scattered over the web to gather sign-ups for your newsletter.
Setup Your Email Sign-Up Box
If you’re using a back-end driven, dynamically generated site such as a CMS (Content Management System — i.e., WordPress, Joomla, Drupal) and you have a “block” or “snippet” for your newsletter sign-up box, you should be able to make one update and have it update across your website instantaneously. If you have more than one website, you’ll need to make this update for each website.
Design Your Newsletter
The last thing you’ll want to copy over is the design templates you use for your enewsletters. Typically you’ll have access to the HTML for these, so copying these over shouldn’t be all too difficult in most services, as most email marketing service providers provide flexible template editing options.
Email Marketing Terminology
As with any new topic, over time, these terms will quickly become second nature to you as you begin using and applying them.
To help you out, we have prepared a comprehensive list of definitions that will equip you with the knowledge and expertise to implement successful email marketing campaigns.
If you have an email marketing term that you’re confused about or we didn’t capture in our list, leave us a comment below.
A/B Testing (Split Testing)
An internet marketing technique that lets you test and see which elements of your email newsletter: subject line, text, graphics, design, or layout, can be improved to increase your newsletter’s success rate. Some email marketing service providers include this feature to help you split test and give you results to find out which performs better.
Application Programming Interface (API)
Most popular Email Marketing Service Providers (EMSPs) now offer what’s called an API (or Application Programming Interface), which allows you to connect/integrate other existing software to the EMSP. Benefits include data sharing, better contact importing, better contact list management and analytic reporting capability, and more.
The options are numerous, depending on your needs and what type of API the EMSP offers. An example of an API would be Salesforce, a popular customer relationship manager (CRM) used for tracking leads. EMSP’s can use the Salesforce API to automatically send out campaigns to segments of your existing database, without having to import or export lists from other programs.
Attachments
Almost all EMSPs do not allowattachments for a simple reason – they increase the probability of a given message being viewed as spam (as a result, the EMSP’s (and your) delivery rates may be affected). Attachments can also be flagged as computer virus files.
For that reason, you’re better off using inline links in your newsletter email, which you can then link to a hosted file. When the user clicks the link, they are given the option to download the file. Not as streamlined as an email attachment, but much more likely to allow the email to reach its full audience.
Autoresponder
An autoresponder fires off an email to a subscriber automatically. A single autoresponder is most common – this typically just replies to a subscriber when they sign up. A sequential autoresponder is a little more advanced and allows you to schedule a series of predefined emails to be sent out on a schedule.
Bounce & Bounce Rate
A bounce is when an email is rejected by the recipient’s mail server. There are two types of bounces. A soft bounce is when an email is temporarily un-receivable due to a full mailbox or email size, and a hard bounce is a permanent fail to deliver.
Emails that have hard bounces should be removed from your email database because they do not exist. Soft bounces, on the other hand, are okay to keep in your database, but you should keep an eye on them over time.
Some EMSP’s will continue to try to send to soft bounce emails several times to attempt success (but not guaranteed). The bounce rate is the percentage of emails that bounce back on your email list. For example, if you have one email out of 10 that bounces back, you would have a 10% bounce rate. If your bounce rate is high, then your account could be flagged for having a large number of undeliverable emails.
CAN-SPAM
A common email term is “CAN-SPAM” which stands for the Controlling the Assault of Non-Solicited Pornography And Marketing Act – or “Canning spam” email. Signed into law in 2003 it contains a series of email marketing guidelines enforced by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to protect U.S. consumers.
Most of these compliance measures are standard in EMSPs including having a mailing address in email campaigns and requiring subscribers to opt in so you shouldn’t have to worry about adhering to them (but you should be aware of CAN-SPAM to make sure you are not breaking the law).
Click-Through Rate
Just as the term states, the click-through rate is the percentage of how many people click on your email campaign. The click rate is used primarily in campaigns with a call to actions that encourage a subscriber to click on a link to buy, read more or sign up (it may be less important in general awareness campaigns).
Some EMSPs like MailChimp show you the industry average click-through rate so you can see how your campaigns compare to others.
Email Marketing Service Providers (EMSPs)
These are companies that provide email marketing services for companies to create, deploy, and track marketing emails. There are a wide-range of services that offer a variety of different bells and whistles, so it’s important to get to know which is the best service for you and what you are trying to achieve.
List Segmentation
List segmentation is targeting messages to subsets of your subscriber base. Customer segmentation can be done using a variety of factors based on data you have captured from your newsletter subscribers when they sign up (like interests, location, etc.).
If you have the time and resources, segmenting your lists is a great way to help establish a stronger connection via more relevant newsletters. A great use of segmentation is to resend messages to subscribers who didn’t open or click the first time.
Opt-In/Opt-Out
The term used for when a subscriber joins your email newsletter. The subscriber must be aware of joining your list before adding them by agreeing to receive email communications from you. Conversely, if someone wishes to remove themselves from your newsletter, you must legally have the option for them to “opt out” within the emails you send.
Open Rate
Similar to click rate, the open rate is much like the name states and is the percentage of opens from a single email campaign. Open rates are often used as a benchmark for success with higher open rates translating to better emails.
Catchy subject lines (see below), frequency, and timing of campaign can all affect the open rate, so it’s good to test out each to get the highest open rate possible.
Newsletter Archiving
This is the ability to save, or archive, your old newsletters. EMSPs differ in the way they handle this feature. Some offer to back up a certain quantity or volume of newsletters on their servers. Others offer export options that convert your newsletters into PDF or HTML files so you can download them and/or store them on your website. You need to keep in mind that there is an SEO advantage to archiving your own newsletters (DIY).
Responsive Design Templates
Given the popularity of smartphones, most email templates are now designed to adjust automatically for viewing on mobile, tablets, and PC screens. There are also mobile-aware designs that are more basic in their design than their responsive counterparts. Ideally, mobile-aware designs render on all screens, but they are geared toward smartphone screens so they can get glitchy.
Responsive design templates are the optimal choice these days as statistics show that consumers are increasingly opening their emails on the go through their smartphones and tablets. If you don’t have a good design that you know will render well on all screens, you risk losing a great opportunity to build and keep your customers. Use your EMSP to preview your email in smartphone mode or send a test and check it on your own device.
Spam Score/Checking
Finding out whether your subscribers actually got your email is important. If they didn’t, why not? Some EMSPs offer spam score utilities that help you determine the likelihood of your newsletter ending up in a spam box before you hit send. Spam tests help you optimize and clean up your email campaign before sending it.
Subject Line
The subject line is the string of text in the subject field of the email. It gives the reader an idea of what to expect and is one of the most important parts of your message.
Think of the subject line as a “hook” to get a subscriber to open the email. While the subject line in traditional email is more informational, the subject line for email marketing should be catchy and engaging, so it catches your audience’s attention. Subject lines should not contain any words that could be flagged as spam-like “FREE” or over-use punctuation marks!!! As emojis become more popular, you are likely to see them used more frequently by marketers. However, emoji use may trigger a message to get caught in the spam filter.
Survey
Email marketing surveys help you capture visitor data. Typically, surveys will let you:
Create public (anyone can answer) or private (only a specified subset of your subscribers can answer) surveys.
Choose different answer formats – text boxes, radio buttons, drop-downs, etc.
Redirect visitors to a custom thank you page upon completion of your survey.
Export survey results to a file or spreadsheet for analysis (i.e., by sorting columns you can gauge responses based on different variables).
Text Version
Some people might choose to receive a text-only version of email because they have a device that does not support HTML. This is not as common as it used to be, as HTML is now the standard email format.
Trigger-Based Messaging
This lets you send messages based on your subscriber’s actions. It creates a more personalized interaction with your audience. Examples of trigger-based messages include a welcome email, a “happy birthday” message, a reminder to renew a subscription, a note that a new version of a product is available, a “we miss you ” note to a subscriber that hasn’t opened a newsletter in a while, etc.
WYSIWYG
Aka What You See Is What You Get. This is used to describe a web editor interface that lets you design newsletter templates using buttons similar to those found in a word processor such as Microsoft Word. Examples of buttons include bold, italic, using headings, insert images, and more.
Does Email Still Reign King? (Video)
Is email marketing still effective? Watch this video to summarize why you should be doing email marketing (if you’re not already) and some additional tips on what to look for in an EMSP.
We reviewed quite a few companies, but if for some reason the email marketing brand you’re looking for wasn’t reviewed, check the comments below where you’ll find that many of our visitors are posting their own reviews and opinions.
Why are you considering signing up or switching to a new email marketing service company? Which one do you like and why?
While attending the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill’s graduate school for journalism and public relations in the late 1990s, Sally began a long career researching and writing about business, technical and scientific topics.
Her decades of experience as well as a passion to stay on top of the latest online tools and resources combine to help small businesses (and freelancers like herself) flourish. Her work has appeared in many notable media outlets, including The Washington Post, Entrepreneur, People, Forbes, Huffington Post, and more.
Disclaimer: This website contains reviews, opinions and information regarding products and services manufactured or provided by third parties. We are not responsible in any way for such products and services, and nothing contained here should be construed as a guarantee of the functionality, utility, safety or reliability of any product or services reviewed or discussed. Please follow the directions provided by the manufacturer or service provider when using any product or service reviewed or discussed on this website.
